This is an old revision of the document!


  1. Process for electing new committee at the AGM
  2. What to do with donated electronics
  3. Use of new space in G10/G11
  4. Any proposals for equipment to purchase
  • Russell D
  • Patrick N
  • David W (minute-taker)
  • Kai B
  • John D
  • Pam
  • Tom G
  • David H
  • Toby S
  • Tarim
  • AGM: DW clarified situation with regards to the BOTLab AGM. Last year's AGM was on 16 April 2013, and according to our constitution this year's must be held within 6 weeks of the date of last year's. DW is currently investigating options for preparing Hackspace annual accounts for submission to Companies House; once this has been done, they can be approved at the AGM.
  • Electing a new committee at the AGM
    • DW and DH clarified the existing system: BOTLab members vote for and against each candidate, who is elected if #for > #against. This has no mechanism for regulating committee size except by limiting #candidates. Every year 1/3 of committee must step down for re-election. No aversion to increasing size of committee…
    • Concerns: system that we have favours incumbents, need to give new people a chance
    • TG: people need to understand that elections are happening and people can join the committee
    • DH: Issue with committee size - how do we regulate this?
    • Issue of new people and regulating sizes are different issues
    • Do we open up voting to the whole membership or just the people at the AGM?
    • TG: have an “associate committee” role in parallel with full committee members - give people an easy route into seeing how the committtee works - PN: perhaps treasurer needs an associate
    • 2 posts will be available at next AGM
    • ⇒ publicise better in advance of next AGM?
    • DH: Hackspace has many members who take part in running of the space/organisation without being on the committee - role of the committee is solely a way of formalising the decision-making process - ⇒ associates not really needed as yet, except for admin! ⇒ before the AGM, committee to discuss and publicise admin roles - ACTION
    • Committee also has a role for ensuring things are done - e.g. random emails from 3rd parties - could just be passed on to mailing list, but committee should filter
    • DH: perhaps there is a role for associates in taking a greater part in e.g. responding to incoming requests - “if anybody *wants* to have access to this list…” as an opt-in
    • Returning to discussion of mechanism: use counting of votes for and against, and choose people with strongest majority? but what if we have multiple unanimous votes?; people apply to specific roles? DH: important to be clear to everyone at the start of the meeting what the system is, e.g. there will be 5 committee members at the end of the meeting and votes count accordingly?
    • PN: have a set period to apply for election; if we have too many candidates *then* we decide how to deal with it?
    • TG: start by saying you have to be at the AGM to vote? With some proxy system to allow for input from people who are unable to attend?
    • TG: if we have too many candidates, get them all to cast lots for places? Only problem is if there is 1 person noone wants to work with…
    • Decision: General consensus on TG's proposal!
  • Destination of donated electronic components (bequeathed to Marcus Valentine who donated them to the Hackspace)
    • TG: has been sorting them - proposes sorting them, picking out a quantity that we could conceiveably use (of the useful ones) and sending others to other hackspaces
    • RD: improvement: before distributing them, make the unwanted ones available to hackspace members if they want for >=1week
    • RD: split up big boxes of resistors first into smaller quantities? but that's a lot of work. Or just keep them in stock if they aren't going to go off?
    • First job is to stock-take so we know what we have
    • Problems with sending to other spaces: don't know if they want them, and have to pay the postage? (get people to come and pick up their own stuff!)
    • TG: happy to sort the ICs, wants 1% resistors kept, not going to do it all! RD will help - make a spreadsheet with all items
    • 3 piles: unsorted, sorted-to-be-kept, surplus (open to membership/other hackspaces/anybody)
    • Jay points out other hackspaces are just getting started and would appreciate any donations - invite them to get in touch!
  • Donations more generally
    • TG: what do we do with other donations? do we accept them, what happens?
    • RD: what if equipment with value turns up? Would be a shame if it was just dumped…
    • Have just instituted 3 bin system]- gives people 3 weeks to express interest. Is 3 weeks long enough? Esp. if we get a big donation that fills the bins?
    • PN: still in beta, will see how it works and adjust accordingly!
    • TG: what if companies tried to use us as a dumping ground? Hasn't really been a problem in the past and we do have a fairly clear policy on what we accept e.g. no CRTs!
  • Use of extra space in G10/G11
    • DH: storage boxes for members - e.g. Really Useful Boxes (strongly suggest that people use those, because they stack) - or just *require* people to use specific box
    • Jay: could get a discount if we buy in bulk - get people to express interest on mailing list
    • Shelving - should we spend money on it? Tarim: has sorted it - we have the frame parts, all we need is wood for the shelves…
    • Buy in a stack of boxes and let members pay for it? Matt V has already bought in some boxes - but maybe invest in a good system for the future. Filing cabinets as a better use of space? Not necessarily for members' personal storage
    • Size of boxes: e.g. RUB 35l & 18l half that height - ~£5 and ~£10
    • ACTION: DH to put a proposal to the mailing list
  • Additional equipment required?
    • (storage - see above)
    • RD: better chairs! something padded, more consistent… Pam: could get office chairs cheaply from auctions (BCVA business auctions in Ashton - also other things)? Diversity is good… “Contemporary and eclectic”!
    • Not enough time to get a committee decision between listing and auction - but someone could get approval to spend up to a certain amount on a certain number of chairs - RD to put a proposal to the list once he has an idea of the figures involved
    • TG: surface-mount soldering equipment? We have a hot-air rework station and Ian's toaster oven, but something a bit more professional? Nudge Ian to provide instructions on use of his oven?
    • DH: hand tools? good screwdrivers etc., tinsnips
    • DH: ask the mailing list! ACTION: DW to organise
    • RD: MarkForged carbon-fibre 3d printer?! $5000, shipping in “second half of 2014”? Tarim: suggest to Knowle West Media Centre as they have big funding…
  • BV Open Studios
    • Tarim: Happening at end of May - Weekend of 31 May/1 June
    • Good opportunity to show our work off
    • PN: make some fliers to distribute? Barney made some for the Maker Faire
  • governance/meetings/2014/0408.1680742431
  • Last modified: 5 months ago
  • (external edit)